November 23, 2023

What to do if your new mortgage interest rate is unaffordable

Mortgages interest rates have increased rapidly. Here’s our advice for handling the cost of mortgage rate increases when renewing your mortgage.

Facebook LinkedIn Whatsapp

What to do if your new mortgage interest rate is unaffordable

A woman with a high mortgage rate explores her options

An increasing number of homeowners are feeling the burden of unaffordable mortgage payments due to high interest rates. The rising cost of mortgages are affecting homeowners of all types. People with variable mortgages will have already seen their rates rise dramatically for months and those continual rises have become unaffordable for some. 

For people with fixed term mortgages having to renew in the coming year, the cost can be shocking and in some (perhaps many) cases it could be unaffordable. Most people who own a house don’t want to sell unless absolutely necessary. So, if your mortgage becomes too expensive what should you do? 

The costly housing ladder

We asked Jennifer McCracken, a BDO Licensed Insolvency Trustee, what these rising interest rates mean for homeowners and who she thinks will be the most affected. 

“Lots of people have scrimped and saved just to get on the housing ladder in recent years. Houses have been expensive that whole time, but mortgage rates have been super low for over a decade. I think people who did everything they could when rates were low to get a house are those most at risk, because they were likely counting on having a lower mortgage rate to help them afford their house in the long-term.”

BDO’s Affordability Index found mortgage costs are the most stressful form of debt for 18% of Canadians. That number is higher for younger people. For those aged 18-34, 22% said their mortgage was their most stressful debt. The largest group was those between 35-54, where it’s 24%.

Only 10% of those 55+ said mortgage payments were their most stressful debt.

Of course, younger people are not the only ones who will be affected by refinancing at a higher rate but it does seem they will be those who struggle with it most. 

Let’s look at some steps to take if you want to keep your house and are worried about rising rates.

Talk to your lender

“The first thing I would do if I was worried about my mortgage is talk to my lender,” says Jennifer McCracken. 

“I would contact the bank and get a sense of mortgage penalties; those will likely vary because it depends a lot on where you live. Discuss making interest only payments. If it’s a variable rate, see if you could do a short-term refinance until renewal. If you want to sell and pull out your equity and downsize you can discuss the possibility of porting your mortgage to a new property.”

Sometimes if you simply ask your lender to lower their offer they will. 

“People are scared to negotiate with their lenders and simply believe the offer they get is a ‘take it or leave it’ option. That’s not the case though. They want your business and will likely do what they can to accommodate you,” Jennifer says.

Struggling with high mortgage rates?

Shop around lenders

When your mortgage is up you don’t need to re-sign with the same lender. It’s more convenient to do so, and that’s what most lenders count on. 

Shopping around means you can compare prices and find the best deal possible. It’s a good idea to get a head start on looking too, usually a few months before your mortgage is up for renewal. Doing so will allow you to see what’s out there early. If you do find something better, you can use it as a negotiating piece with your current lender to see if they’ll lower their rate. 

If they won’t lower their offer, you can then sign with the new lender at a better rate without having to scramble.

Consider a short term-mortgage

This one may be the riskiest option, but some believe it is a good idea right now. Most Canadian fixed term mortgages are five-year terms, but you can get one-to-three-year fixed term mortgages as well. 

Many believe that interest rates have hit their peak and will now fall in coming years. If you have a short-term mortgage in that case, you can take advantage of lower rates in a few years. 

The risk here is if interest rates rise again you’ll be forced to negotiate at an even higher price than now.

What if you can’t get a rate you can afford?

Renting and downsizing 

We know most people who buy homes don’t want to sell. Sometimes though it’s unavoidable. The idea of renting can work for some people whose mortgage has become unaffordable but it depends on where you live and what you do for a living, Jennifer McCracken says. 

“If you live in Toronto, Vancouver, Montreal or any other large city in the country it’s probably not an option because rent would be the same as a mortgage payment but there are areas of the country, usually less populated ones, where the cost difference between rent and a mortgage is a pretty big gap. That can add up to big savings.”

“I wouldn’t suggest it to everyone in a rural area. I know people like farmers livelihoods depends on them living in the house next to their crop field. You need the exact right circumstances for this.” 

If renting isn’t an option maybe downsizing is. Moving to a smaller home can reduce your mortgage costs and save you money. 

Some lenders will even allow you to port (this essentially means ‘transfer’) your mortgage to a new property without a penalty. 

Others will come with a penalty fee. Be sure to talk to your lender to see how downsizing will affect you and your mortgage before taking any action.

Cut spending and consider a side hustle

If you get a new rate an realize it’s just a tiny bit beyond what you feel comfortable with, the first thing you have to do is cut spending, McCracken says. 

“Maybe that means eating only home cooked meals, changing the grocery store you shop at for a cheaper one, cutting a subscription you have, driving less to save on gas, changing your phone or internet provider or a combination of these.” 

If you have the opportunity to do more work on a part-time or gig work basis it can make a big difference as well. We know this won’t be something everyone can do though. 

For those that can, it can make a big difference to help afford any increase in the cost of a mortgage.

What if you don’t want to sell/downsize, can’t afford your mortgage rate increase and getting a new source of income either won’t be enough or isn’t possible? 

Can a consumer proposal save a mortgage?

consumer proposal is a tool that helps people lower their unsecured debt, a house is a secured asset though. So, would filing a consumer proposal even be of any use? 

The answer is yes. Here’s how. 

While a consumer proposal can’t directly help you lower your mortgage payments, it can make paying your mortgage easier. Consumer proposals can reduce your unsecured debts by up to 80%. 

There of lots of examples of unsecured debt a consumer proposal can help lower. If you have debt from credit cards, lines of credit, student loans, a personal loan, or any combination of these, they can all be reduced with a consumer proposal. 

“The benefit is it lowers your unsecured debt payments, freeing up more money for your mortgage,” Jennifer McCracken points out. 

A consumer proposal is also interest free. So, while you can’t file a consumer proposal directly to lower your mortgage payments, filing one to reduce your other debts can make finding the money for a mortgage much easier. 

Another advantage to a consumer proposal is unlike bankruptcy, you don’t lose any assets.

How do you get a consumer proposal?

A consumer proposal is done when a Licensed Insolvency Trustee negotiates with your creditors on your behalf to reduce your debt. Only a Licensed Insolvency Trustee is legally allowed to file a consumer proposal for you in Canada. 

The first step is to have a Licensed Insolvency Trustee evaluate your financial situation. They will deem if a proposal can help you and then begin the process of negotiating with your creditors to reduce your debt. 

The first meeting to evaluate your financial standing often takes less than an hour. The first consultation with one of BDO’s Licensed Insolvency Trustees is completely free too. 

If you’ve been offered a rate hike you can’t afford and don’t want to sell, talk to one of our Trustees and see if a consumer proposal is right for you. 

Do you have more questions?

Check out our related content


November 23, 2023

What to do if your new mortgage interest rate is unaffordable

Mortgages interest rates have increased rapidly. Here’s our advice for handling the cost of mortgage rate increases when renewing your mortgage.

Facebook LinkedIn Whatsapp