In this example, a woman named Mary is carrying $25,000 in credit card debt. She files a consumer proposal, and a Licensed Insolvency Trustee negotiates with her creditors so that she only must repay 60 per cent of her debt, or $15,000, over a period of five years. Here’s how her consumer proposal compares to other debt relief solutions:
|
Mary’s Consumer Proposal |
Credit Counselling |
Debt Consolidation Loan |
“Do-it-yourself” Budgeting |
Monthly payment |
$250 |
$458.88 |
$734.67 |
$994.34 |
Terms |
Pay back 60% of original amount owed |
Pay back debt in full with no interest, plus a “fair share fee” equal to 10% of debt |
Pay debt in full at 12% interest, compounded annually |
Pay back debt in full at 19% interest, compounded annually |
Repayment period |
Five years |
Five years |
Five years |
Five years |
Any form of unsecured debt (debt that is not backed, or secured, by an asset you own—like how a mortgage loan is secured by your house) can be included in a consumer proposal. Types of unsecured debt include:
Credit cards
Lines of credit
Personal loans
Payday loans
Income taxes
While both a consumer proposal and a bankruptcy can give you a fresh financial start, there are a few key differences, as follows:
When you a file a consumer proposal, you cannot have more than $250,000 in debt. There is no maximum when you file for bankruptcy.
With a consumer proposal, you will pay the same amount to your Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) every month; in bankruptcy, the monthly amount you pay can vary based on your surplus income.
Most importantly, when you file a consumer proposal, you will not lose any of your assets. By filing bankruptcy, some of your assets will likely be sold to repay a portion of the debt owed to your creditors.